5:17am, Thu 9th Feb, 2012 (NYC)

american beheaded in iraq
..posted by Nereus at 7:25PM on Tuesday 11 May, 2004  |  30 comments     

I wrote quite a long and angry post about this horrifying act after seeing the unedited version of the video (or at least as much as I could stomach before having to turn it off, which wasn't much). No doubt you are aware of what happened. I have removed my original post as it was just angry ranting. All I will say is this:

The degradation of prisoners by US soldiers was a reprehensible and deplorable act and those responsible will be dealt with severely, but what I have seen regarding the mistreatment of those prisoners does not hold a candle against what was done to Nicholas Berg. Nothing can justify what was done to Nicholas Berg. NOTHING.

The slaughter captured on that video goes way beyond the realms of being in any way possibly considered an act of sane men fighting for what they believe is justice or freedom or belief or retribution or whatever other reason they might come up with. What is captured on that video is the act of a pack of psychopathic uncivilized animals.

In some ways it would be a good idea to air the full video on the international media to give some perspective to all the publicity about the prisoner abuse that is being aired currently. I can almost guarantee you that after seeing the video, it would change the negative feelings many people hold about the US being in Iraq. Hearing about it is one thing, seeing it is a whole different story. The inhumanity of it would turn a lamb into an angry lion, it is that bad.

At this moment, and as a direct result of that video, I am in full support of troops being in Iraq and hope they start kicking ass big time. I know that is not a very reasoned statement, but I don't give a shit. No mercy.


30 comments

its all ugly if you ask me. americans are raping and torturing iraquis. iraquis beheading an american. its just all so sickening. nothing seems worse than the other to me. all if it is disgusting.


Just announced on the news was that his parents are blaming the Bush administration for it, despite the fact that when Nicholas was jailed in Iraq earlier this year the CIA got him out and gave him a plane ticket back to the US, which he refused.


I agree that it was horrific. I saw the footage only half an hour ago...it is so grisly that I still fill sick. But which is better? US soldiers allegedly torturing iraqi's to death (slowly) or a comparatively swift beheading? Trust me...there is evil aplenty on BOTH sides. And Bush is just a wanker for inflaming the Muslim world to begin with.


I'm not aware (as yet) that any Iraqis were tortured to death, although that doesn't make the humiliation those prisoners suffered ok.

What started all this was 911, or if you want to go back further, it was Iraq invading Kuwait. Those responsible inflamed the US, not the other way around. People seem to be forgetting that.


I've been getting a shitload of hits and people asking where I saw the unedited video.
You can find it now at ogrish.com apparently. Thanks(?) to a link from slothmud forums for that.


i havent seen the video, i want to see for myself i just dont get it from the words of others, will someone please give me the url for the site it is at? thanks..


err.. see the comment just before yours?


Nothing justifies murder, however 650+ Iraqi civilians died in the American offensive on Fallujah two weeks ago. Americans never seem to hear news reports about Iraqi casualties, or if they do, it never seems to register. 650 Iraqis to 1 American seems like a high proportion to me. And yes, Iraqis have been tortured to death at the prison, and elsewhere in Iraq, as well as Afghanistan. What will it take to convince your country you do not have the right to rape and murder "for freedom"????? I've been wondering all my life what is wrong with you people? Don't you have hearts? Have you heard of compassion for all beings? Why do you seem to hate and fear the rest of the world to the point of irrationality???


Petaluda99 theres not one single bit of evidence to show there have been deaths at the prisons and the only people who claim there have been are fucktards like you who arent even there and have no proof at all so how the fuck would you know? Lots of civs killed but that is because because they are used as shields by these fucking cowards. Take your anti-American shit and shove it up your ass you dumb whore.


I was on drugs when I wrote that last post. You know me. I was sitting in the coffee shop smoking pot and doing crank, when I thought what better way to start shit than to blame all of my problems on Americans.

I know that Americans are the very people that fought/died/ and finally saved our pathetic lives in WW1 WW2 and various other wars and conflicts.

Hell if it wasn't for them I'd speak japanese or German right now.

I just get mad that some people do good for others. How dare those americans help people? Who do they think they are? They should sit around and bitch like me and do nothing. Then nobody would hate them. We would all live in peace for a day or two and then we would never have to worry about this garbage again. Do you know why? BECAUSE THE WORLD WOULD BE OVERRUN WITH THUGS and KILLERS. Hell on EArth? Well maybe not that bad, but it wouldn't be far from the truth


Cut the crap! If everybody is guilty, then everybody is innocent. To make an equal comparison with the FACTS of American misdemeanors in Iraq (actually not much more than a very serious fraternity hazing gone very wrong - this stuff about slow deaths is nonsense) with the complete disregard for the most basic civilized vales as demonstrated by that cowardly act (they are too chicken-shit to come out and fight in the open) is to contribute to a world environment in which these animals can thrive. You may as well compare the raping of German women after world war II by French occupyers with the Holocaust - gee I guess the Nazis are no worse than everyone else duh! Have you no sense of perspective? And have you no real loyalty to the American vision and this country? Do you hate yourselves so much? However we need to face reality, the arab world is barbaric and backward and Islam has never been a religion of "peace", arab "civilization" is directly opposite to the values we proclaim as sacred (like for instance women actually have rights). But it is in our national interests and within our rights of self-defense to be there, and if these people continue in this way, perhaps we should geniunely begin acting as conquerors and crusaders. As world war II ended we had no problem with leveling an entire town if an american soldier was killed there - perhaps we should give the world a lesson in naked american power - and just maybe they will learn to repect and fear us again (because their jealousy and envy will never allow them to be our "friends"). Oh yeah, President Bush is the best president this country has had since FDR, so many of you hate him, because unlike Clinton, Gore, and Kerry, he is a real and strong! If Kerry should be elected, it would be a disaster. Why? Because he is a complete clown!


Hmm I've had some visitors. Nearly 10,000 today alone according to the counter. Firstly, checking IPs regarding the previous three comments before Nathan's, the first (and obviously legit) comment from petaluda99 traces back through to AOL in Sterling, Virginia. The second comment by 'American' apparently came from Parsippany in New Jersey via Insight Broadband who presumably resell AT&T's network. The third comment was made from the same IP again in case you had any doubts ...just thought I'd clear that one up.

petaluda99, or Ann as I think your actual name is, I was fascinated reading a portion of your website, I will be back to read further when time permits. Back on-topic, I'll reply to your comment. First of all, this entry you commented on was written while I was very angry about what I saw on that video, and it can be hard sometimes to think clearly while in such an aggravated state. Had you seen the original entry I wrote, one thing you would have noticed is that I made it very clear that if it was Americans doing that to an Iraqi on that video, I'd feel the same way towards them; I don't care who did it, it was the psychotic act itself and possibly moreso the fact that they wanted everyone to see it that really got to me.

I believe you are Canadian but living in the US? Then you'd know what the media does and doesn't include in their reports here in the US (btw, I've lived in New Zealand most of my life until moving to NYC the day before 911). I didn't know about the high civilian death rate at Fallujah two weeks ago, and I don't think the figures you gave are outside the realms of possibility either. I would not however believe that US enlisted soldiers would ruthlessly torture Iraqis to death. Contractors or mercenaries, yes maybe. Rumours about "rape and murder" etc always persist in times of conflict; whether they are initiated by insurgents in order to stir up anger and thus support for their cause, or they are initiated by the alleged torturers in order to instill fear and therefore submission, I do not know. Until there is evidence of this, then it must be treated in exactly the same way that you no doubt view the original allegations about Iraq having WMD: it is not true unless there is proof. If you personally do not believe that Hussein had WMD or was trying to make them, then by believing that US soldiers are raping and murdering innocent Iraqis without any proof, you are completely contradicting yourself. Think about it.

"Have you heard of compassion for all beings? Why do you seem to hate and fear the rest of the world to the point of irrationality?"
I think (hope) that maybe you're doing exactly what I did when I heard the news about Nicholas Berg; you're angry and you're responding with your emotions.

Worth noting at this point is that US Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld allegedly approved the use of 'harsh' interrogation techniques in the Iraqi theatre on condition that the commanding general gave approval 'prior to employment. This included sleep management, sensory deprivation, isolation, making detainees hold 'stress' positions and similar such actions. All apparently within the Geneva Convention... *raises an eyebrow*

Another point of view I read on a forum which was, well, interesting, was that; "it may be better in this arena for the US if they continued on the current route and were perceived as having a nutball for president. If other countries think the US will invade if provoked, regardless of how dumb an idea it is or the cost to the US, they're a lot less likely to provoke them."

To Nathan who commented "the arab world is barbaric and backward" (although that is taken out of context, but..) that view is a matter of perspective though. Some other cultures (not neccessarily just Arabian culture) no doubt think the western culture is barbaric and backward, or at least full of evil heathens with no sense of moral decency (re females exposing flesh and such crap). Although I don't agree with their point of view in that regard, I thought that was worth mentioning.


Hey Nereus,
Might help if you pick your titles a little better. There are some really sick people out there and when you post a buzz word topic, they will show up as trolls on your blog. Actually, it might also be good as you will also meet some folks that may have just been checking to see what bloggers are saying about the topic and showed up that way. They might be contributers to your blog, so bad or good, at least you got some exposure. I myself showed up as you visited my blog and I feel we have some things in common.
Onward with this topic, i have been hearing some interesting stuff about Nick Berg on some of the talk radio stations I listed to while on some of the many parking lots (freeways) here in San Diego, as i am going to and from work/school/jury duty. I guess some pretty unglamorous things may be coming out about this guy over the next couple of days. This guy may have been involved in the OK City bombing, and the World Trade Center attack. I'm not going to say he was, but there are some intersting things coming out about this guy, allowing terrorists use his e-mail account and that the FBI had him under survallence back before the OK City bombing. This is going to be very interesting. Well I guess thats it for tonight. I hope that your troll count will go down over the next couple of days, my freind.


For those who say the Arab world is "primitive and barbaric" -- please watch American TV for a week and ask yourself what is "advanced and civilized" about that?

I've travelled in Egypt and met people who were extremely kind, hospitable, sensitive, well-educated. In fact, this experience caused me to wonder about the values of the supposedly superior West. Travel is healthy.

People who get all their information about the world from Fox News are mentally disadvantaged. It's truly scary to watch US television news -- it poisons the whole world, turning it into a "survival of the fittest, US vs Them" nightmare.

I feel sorry for Americans, the richest nation on earth, and also the most information-starved. I think even in the former Soviet Union, people had a better sense of the world outside their borders than Americans do today.

Thanks for your message, Nereus! Nice visiting your blog. Keep up the good work.


I saw the video, and it made me sick for quite a while too. After the initial shock, I realized that they are trying to convey a message Americans just don't seem to want to hear--they really, really, really want Americans to understand that they really, really, really don't want us there and don't like us. Pretty simple. And if any of the reports about Berg's methods of travel are true, then while I don't think he deserved ANY of what happened, he certainly could have been a little more careful. He was young and probably under the misguided notion that a lot of Americans desperately want to believe--that Iraq loves and welcomes us. No, they fucking *hate* us, just like most of the Middle East and frankly the rest of the world. There's a reason for that.

Lastly, not all the photos and videos of what Americans did to Iraqi prisoners have been released to the media. A LARGE percentage has not. This is a very important point to keep in mind when you are comparing 'us' vs. 'them'. Congress has seen some of this larger portion, and it made then sick the way it made us sick watching the Berg thing. There was some seriously depraved shit going on there.

Several prisoners were beaten to death by our soldiers--a method of dying that is much more painful and slower than a beheading. Hell, we did some crap in Vietnam that made the Berg thing look tame (My Lai, anyone? They bayoneted babies, my friends). So let's not kid ourselves about the American violations. We are no better.


Interesting development.. within the last few hours the head of the Iraqi Governing Council (basically what would possibly be the President of Iraq) was assassinated, and not only that, a US convoy was attacked with, wait for it, nerve gas. Yup, sarin, y'know, that stuff also known as a WMD that does not exist in Iraq according to everyone who likes yelling opposition to the US being in Iraq. Good one.


Ok just to clarify that a little: Preliminary field tests show that it is sarin. The shell contained two chemicals which, when mixed during the flight of an artillery shell, formed the nerve agent. The shell had been rigged as an improvised explosive device that resulted in a small dispersal of the agent when it exploded before an ordnance team could disarm it. The artillery round was of an old style that Saddam Hussein's regime had declared it no longer possessed after the Persian Gulf War and it appeared that whoever set up the roadside bomb was unaware that it contained the chemicals. Another shell, this one containing mustard gas, was found 10 days ago in Iraq.


why would anyone want to watch this video? it's enough to read about what happened to feel shocked and listless for a long while. the video should really be off limits, it's just not right that it's out there and anyone can watch this guy be brutalized like that.
and i'm sorry, but his death was a consequence of a series of decisions and actions made under the supervision of bush and his administration. shameless brutality under the guise of a humanitarian mission. that's fucking evil.


Yeah but you can use the exact same logic and take it a bit further to say his death was a consequence of a series of decisions and actions made by Saddam Hussein which in turn caused Bush to step in etc etc.

Or you could say his death was a consequence of the mindset in which the terrorists were brought up in during their early formative years, so blame their parents.

What you CAN say, without there being any chance of debate, is that his death was a consequence of having his head chopped off.

Not nice I know, and I'm not trying to make a joke of it, but I'm starting to think that debating who is ultimately responsible is futile. All you can really do if you want to remain impartial is to point the finger at the nutcase wielding the knife that actually did it.


i'm surprised that a very similar murder of american journalist daniel pearl two years ago in pakistan didn't cause such an outbreak of publicity, including internet discussions. or maybe i'm forgetting. it's all terrifying, what can i say.

i guess what i'm trying to say, though, is that the sodomy that went on in iraqi prisons is equally horrifying. and the fact that it was done within the framework of "noble doings," of overthrowing a dictatorship, freeing a subdued people, makes it doubly so. i'm going overseas this summer, and i no doubt will feel like shit telling people where i am from. the land of unimaginable hypocrisy.


Yeah I certainly can see your point. The acts committed by those prison guards are (hopefully) not typical or an accurate reflection of the way the majority of the US and coalition forces conduct themselves, and by the same token, the acts of those terrorists are not a accurate reflection on the way the majority of Iraqis conduct themselves either. Unfortunately those acts are what gets the attention of the world, and many people formulate a stereotype from that alone.

With Daniel Pearl the same thing was done - decapitation. There was a lot of publicity about it at the time too from what I remember.


I just spent nearly an hour trying to type out a coherent, reasonable response to this. I have not seen the video, nor do I wish to. On that note, I commend you, Nereus, for not putting the video on your site, and for not reccommending others view it.

I heard a radio personality talking about the video, and even just hearing second-hand what Nick Berg went through in the moments before his death, I felt nauseous, and ultimately switched the radio to a different station because I didn't want to throw up in my car.

No matter what horrible things have been perpetrated by US military personnel in Iraq, Vietnam, Japan, [insert any battlefield the Stars and Stripes have ever flown over here], etc, there was no justification for what those men did to Mr. Berg.

Retaliation against those soldiers personally responsible for the prisoner abuse would be one thing, but to kidnap a civilian, then videotape his brutal, inhumane torture and murder, then post it on the Internet for the entire world to see is just sick.

This Nick Berg killing is not about the US being right or wrong in their occupation of Iraq. It's not about George Bush's competence or lack thereof. It's about hate, pure and simple. The men who killed Berg hate the US, they hate Jews, and they hate anyone who disagrees with them. There is no way to negotiate with someone like that. There is no way to peacefully resolve a conflict with someone like that.

These terrorists will continue to kill with no regard to their victims' innocence or guilt until they run out of enemies or they themselves are dead. That is what the mainstream media and the general public in the Western World does not seem to recognize.

People want so desperately to believe that peace can be gained without bloodshed that they rationalize away the brutal killing of an innocent civilian by our enemies while seeking out every bad seed in our own camp and making them appear to be the norm.

It's as if the United States has assumed the role of global janitor, trying to clean up messes all over the planet while the rest of the world condemns us for getting our hands dirty in the process. It makes me sick.


wow...im m very disturbed from watching the nick berg n Kim Sun-il videos...very speechless n disgusted.......


where the fucks the video?!!


Try reading the comments, or is that too much to ask?


I do not like to go to message boards like this but I want to tell any americans that YOU NEED TO LOOK TO THE VIDEO WHERE THE BRITISH GUY IS ASKING FOR HIS LIFE. It is so sad. I am not saying we deserve what is going on out there and they dont but I am saying Britian is not control freaks or trying to take over on lie there. I am ALWAYS SAYING that why do we have places there that they only show on the news for a fast time. Probably not thinking that we saw the WOMEN AND CHILDEN we had taken as prisoners. That was long ago when they showed that. Even before the war started we knew it was coming and there we not any weapons as they said. It was a sad day when we hear why my country was going to do. It is even sadder that we are going to drag it out so long now. I HAVE A GREAT HATE FOR THE USA NOW EVEN MORE SO THAN BEFORE. It is sad that so many in one country can be so stupid and so violent. Listen to last parts that are spoken by the British prisoner. My God he is a wise man. I wish we had more here that were that smart. If we just let the women and childen go home there and get the fuckin usa asses out of there from taking control .. well if we had brain maybe we would.
Leigh Girlweb page
I put my webpage up since there is not much on my site now so if you go there and want to vent to me in my chat room and say stupid things then i just wont speak to any americans that day.. hum i seldom do. We know why now. Some that are cool are welcome


Of course it's sad, but why do you hate the US so much? Forget the WMD, Saddam Hussein was murdering tens of thousands of innocent Iraqis and bought the country to poverty conditions while he built dozens of extravagant palaces for himself all over Iraq, using the blood of Iraqis to pay for it. Is that somehow ok in comparison? Yes, it is sad that one country can be so violent, but perhaps you're pointing your finger at the wrong country?

What I find hard so understand is how it's ok for one 'side' to ignore all the geneva conventions etc and kidnap and execute civilians on video, pretend to surrender then shoot or blow themselves up as US soldiers approach, shoot from inside of mosques etc, yet gawd forbid the US soldiers comb their hair the wrong way.. it's such a contradiction.

I didn't see what the Brit guy said on the video (I saw part of one execution video and I don't want to see any more.. it was horrifying), but if you want to tell me what he said, please do. Personally I hope the coalition troops get out of Iraq as soon as possible and let the people of Iraq run their own country because war means death, and the loss of human life is not good, regardless of which 'side' it's on.

Yes having woman and children as prisoners is pretty harsh, but hey, the US aren't chopping their heads off and showing it on international television.

Sorry you hate the US so much, but thanks for your comments anyway.


I cant go to Ogrish.com because of our DLSZ web filter made from our school. BAD TRIP


i think that its not right for people should go through this


add a comment